Submit your event / occasion details to see a personalised list of Pie And Mash Caterers in Sheffield available to book instantly.Read more
Best Pie And Mash Caterers in Sheffield
Craving a taste of classic British comfort food? Discover Sheffield’s best Pie and Mash catering for hire, perfect for bringing a heartwarming, traditional touch to your next event! We’ve hand-picked 3 fantastic suppliers in Sheffield, offering everything from classic steak and ale to vegetarian options, served with creamy mash and delicious liquor. Ideal for relaxed wedding receptions at Sheffield Botanical Gardens, private parties at The Chimney House, or corporate gatherings.
Every pie and mash caterer on this list has been personally vetted by our team, ensuring exceptional food quality, professional service, and a proven track record at events across Sheffield.
The average price for our Pie and Mash catering in Sheffield is around £16 per guest, or approximately £850 per event, with the final cost depending on your chosen menu, guest numbers, and any additional requirements.
Our Sheffield Pie and Mash suppliers have collectively served 70 events, gathering 19 verified client reviews and boasting a perfect 5.00* average rating!
5.0(13 reviews)
• 20 bookings
Tasty Pie & Mash From Our Vintage Horsebox
Pie & Mash is extremely popular and a great choice for events and celebrations all served from our wonderful horsebox
from £19 / person
Why event planners love Poptop
Reviews for Best Pie And Mash Caterers in Sheffield
Read verified reviews from real clients, who booked with Poptop in Sheffield
S
Steve Bartlett26 Mar 2023
Great service from a lovely friendly team. Everyone loved the pies. John made a point of keeping in touch and updating me and was totally reliable. Would not hesitate to recommend this company- Thank you guys
L
Linzi10 Oct 2022
John and Tracy supplied pies for our birthday party. The food was delicious, and the service was excellent. I will definitely be using them again in the future and would have no problems recommending The Handmade Pie Company.
L
Lisa Travers10 Sep 2022
Romanelli provided freshly cooked gorgeous pizza for our wedding guests. Easy to communicate with and a professional friendly team. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed and I wouldn't hestitate to recommend them! Thank you
H
Helen1 Jun 2022
Great food at a great price. Everyone said how good the pie's tasted and option of gravy too.. Arrived promptly and was ready to serve as soon as our guests were ready to eat. Great set up and even though we had true British summer weather, rain he had it covered. Would recommend Jamie and his pies to make your event a success.
C
Cathy Jury30 May 2022
Jamie was just brilliant! Booking and communication was very good before the event. He arrived at the venue on time and set the cab up for service without any fuss. The food was delicious - we have had comments from our guests complimenting the food and the 'Black Cab'.
Can't thank you enough :) Excellent food and service!
S
Stew1 Dec 2018
"Outstanding. I couldn’t recommend these guys more. The food was really good, they catered for everyone’s needs and the communication back and forth was quick and professional.
They contributed to making our wedding perfect in everyway.
Thank you for everything"
We delivered next level parties for exceptional companies
We also did more than 40,000 birthday parties. Probably, including your neighbour’s recent big bash.
Pie and Mash Caterers in Sheffield: A Proper Buyer’s Guide for Comfort Food Done Right
If you’re searching for pie and mash caterers in Sheffield, first of all, excellent choice. Few things bring people together faster than proper comfort food served hot, hearty and without fuss. No foam, no tiny portions, no confusion. Just golden pastry, rich fillings and a generous helping of mash. Jobs a good’un.
We’ve helped plan more events than we’ve had hot dinners (and that’s saying something), and pie and mash catering keeps popping up for weddings, family celebrations and community gatherings across the city. It’s familiar, filling and brilliantly flexible. From laid back village hall parties to stylish industrial venues, it just works.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through how to choose the right pie and mash caterer in Sheffield, what to expect on price, how to match the food to your venue and theme, and how to make the whole process smooth and stress free.
Let’s get stuck in.
Why Pie and Mash Works So Well for Sheffield Events
Sheffield crowds appreciate honest food. Pie and mash lands perfectly with that northern comfort buffet vibe. It’s warm, generous and welcoming, which is exactly what most hosts want their event to feel like.
It also ticks some very practical boxes:
easy to serve quickly to large groups
suits mixed age ranges
works indoors and outdoors
handles British weather nicely
can be made veggie, vegan or gluten free without drama
Unlike delicate plated dining, pie and mash is built for real life events. Guests can chat, stand, sit, wander and still eat happily without balancing architectural food towers.
Best Occasions for Pie and Mash Catering
We see pie and mash caterers in Sheffield booked again and again for a few key event types. If your event fits one of these, you’re already on the right track.
Weddings with Personality
Not every couple wants formal three course dining. Plenty prefer relaxed, sociable food that feels personal. Pie and mash fits beautifully into:
relaxed receptions
evening wedding food
rustic or industrial venue weddings
winter weddings
budget conscious weddings that still want quality
It’s also a cracking late evening food option once the dancing starts and everyone suddenly “finds room” again.
Family Celebrations
For birthdays, anniversaries and big reunions, pie and mash is a safe bet that still feels special when done by a good caterer.
POPTOP CHOICE 😎
5.0(20 reviews)
• 54 bookings
Traditional Pie & Mash Served From London Taxi
I’ve catered a wide range of events and even appeared on ITV’s This Morning. I serve delicious food with a smile and ensure your event runs smoothly from start to finish.
from £14 / person
Pie And Mash Caterers spotlight 🌟
Delicious British Traditional Pie & Mash Van
4.79(75 reviews)
• 382 bookings
Hiring a Pie and Mash van is your chance to allow everyone to enjoy what is one of the great British traditional foods. So popular, and for so long, is pie and mash that it even has its own Wikipedia page! It’s a terrific way to serve a traditional British pub favourite to your guests.
About supplier
KK Catering are the UK's leading wedding event and party caterer. With over 15 years of experience, we are the number one trusted street food catering company specialising in cuisines from all over the world. Trusted by companies such as DHL, DPD, Virgin Media, Nandos, and Amazon.
from £1200 / event
Instant Quote
Explore thousands of party experiences with live pricing & availability for all our catalogue.
Booking Protection
Book with peace of mind and benefit from booking protection and money-back guarantee.
Curated suppliers
All Poptop’s suppliers are rigorously vetted and approved by our team of party experts, ensuring you book the very best.
happy grandparents and picky kids at the same time
If Auntie Jean and your five year old nephew both approve, you’ve nailed it.
Community and Local Events
Sheffield community events, club gatherings and neighbourhood celebrations often need food that’s scalable and efficient. Pie and mash caterers are built for volume without losing quality.
They’re ideal for:
fundraisers
club dinners
local festivals
society gatherings
sports presentations
It’s comfort food that feels inclusive rather than fancy, which is often exactly the brief.
Matching Pie and Mash to Sheffield Venues
One of the biggest advantages of pie and mash catering is how well it adapts to different spaces. We’ve seen it served everywhere from polished concrete warehouses to village halls with a slightly suspicious thermostat.
Industrial and Warehouse Style Venues
Sheffield has plenty of characterful industrial spaces. Pie and mash fits right in. The contrast between raw surroundings and comforting food actually enhances the experience.
Caterers can usually set up with:
hot holding units
serving counters
mobile kitchens
compact prep areas
Ask about power needs and floor space early. Good caterers will tell you exactly what they require.
Village Halls and Community Spaces
These are made for this kind of catering. Easy access, practical layouts and sensible serving flows.
Check:
kitchen access
serving hatch options
parking for catering vans
setup time windows
Most experienced pie and mash teams have worked dozens of these spaces and can adapt quickly.
Outdoor Picnics and Open Air Events
Yes, even outdoors. Many pie and mash caterers in Sheffield offer mobile setups designed for festivals and open air gatherings.
Key questions to ask:
how they keep food hot
weather backup plans
ground surface requirements
shelter needs
If they answer calmly and clearly, you’re in safe hands.
What You’ll Typically Pay in Sheffield
Let’s talk numbers, because budgets matter and surprises are only fun on birthdays.
Most pie and mash catering in Sheffield sits around £9 to £14 per person, depending on:
number of guests
menu variety
dietary alternatives
staffing included
travel distance
service duration
At the lower end, you’re usually looking at a focused menu with one or two pie options and standard mash and gravy.
At the higher end, you may get:
multiple pie choices
premium fillings
sides and extras
full staffed service
upgraded presentation
Always check what’s included. “Per person” should mean actually per person, not per person plus five add ons and a mystery surcharge.
Menu Options Worth Asking About
Not all pie and mash menus are created equal. Some caterers offer a surprisingly broad range while others specialise in doing a few options extremely well.
Ask what’s possible with:
meat varieties
vegetarian and vegan pies
gluten free pastry
gravy options
mash variations
side dishes
Some caterers also offer themed twists to suit your northern comfort buffet style, without turning it into something unrecognisable.
If you’ve got dietary needs in your guest list, raise them early. Good caterers are used to adapting.
Service Styles You Can Choose From
Pie and mash doesn’t have to mean one fixed format. Different service styles suit different events.
Common options include:
buffet style service
served counter stations
plated service
street food style stalls
roaming service for festivals
Tell the caterer how formal or relaxed you want things to feel. They’ll recommend the best approach.
How to Spot a Quality Pie and Mash Caterer
Photos are nice. Promises are nicer. Proof is nicest.
When choosing pie and mash caterers in Sheffield, look for:
clear menus
transparent pricing
fast replies
proper food hygiene credentials
realistic serving capacities
confident answers about logistics
Ask how many guests they can serve per hour. If they hesitate, that’s a yellow flag. Experienced teams know their throughput.
Making Planning Quick and Painless
One thing we always say: booking catering shouldn’t feel like applying for a mortgage.
The best planning experiences happen when you can:
see instant all inclusive prices
get quick supplier replies
confirm availability fast
understand exactly what’s included
That’s why using a single event marketplace makes life easier. Instead of chasing five suppliers and waiting days for quotes, you can compare matched options quickly and move on with your life.
Your time’s valuable. Spend it choosing music, not chasing menus.
Getting a Caterer That Adapts to You
No two events are identical. Good pie and mash caterers know that and build flexibility into their service.
You should be able to request:
menu tweaks
dietary adjustments
serving time changes
portion planning help
layout adaptations
Your event should feel like yours, not like you’ve squeezed into someone else’s package.
Booking With Confidence, Not Fingers Crossed
Food is too important to gamble on. When you book through a vetted marketplace, you get added peace of mind because suppliers are pre checked and performance matters.
That gives you:
verified professionals
backup support if needed
clear communication
secure booking
financial protection
It means you can relax instead of wondering whether your caterer will vanish the night before. We prefer sleeping at night, personally.
Bringing It All Together
Pie and mash catering in Sheffield is one of the smartest choices you can make if you want food that’s warm, sociable and widely loved. It suits weddings, family celebrations and community events. It works in industrial venues, village halls and outdoor spaces. It keeps budgets sensible and guests happy.
Choose a caterer who communicates clearly, prices transparently and adapts to your needs. Use a trusted marketplace so you can compare options quickly and book with confidence. Keep the menu focused, the service style appropriate and the portions generous.
If you’re planning an event and want comfort food that actually comforts, pie and mash is calling your name. Get your date, guest count and postcode ready, explore your matched caterers, and get it booked. Your future guests are already hungry.
