The handmade pie company

Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Verified bookings: 19
Reviews: 13
Book Safely - confirm booking via Poptop to receive Health & Safety Guarantee

Services From The handmade pie company in Sheffield

The handmade pie company

Handmade Pie Mash With Peas & Gravy. "Check out our reviews"

We are a husband and wife team that takes pride in the pies we make. Packed full of ingredients and made personally to order for your event.
From: £12 per person

Media Files

4 Photos


Price from: £6.75 per person

Bringing your amazing handmade pies with creamy buttery mash, Mushy peas and lashings of gravy

13 Reviews
Certified review

Simon Reader

• Sept. 30, 2023

Fantastic service and fantastic food and fantastic people big thumbs up 👍👍👍

Certified review

Heidi Richardson

• Aug. 12, 2023

Genuinely could not have asked for a better caterer. We had John & his lovely wife come along to cater our surprise wedding and they were absolutely wonderful.
The pies were amazing, everyone has commented on them since. But also everyone had commented on what lovely people they were too.
I would recommend to anyone!! Thank you so much

Certified review

Abi Palmer

• May 25, 2023

INCREDIBLE PIES - INCREDIBLE SERVICE! Still can’t get over how lovely John and Tracy were, and I honestly still dream of the pies. I have a gluten intolerance and they were great at supporting all of the many tricky dietary requirements at our wedding.

Right from our enquiry about availability, through planning our pie selection, to attending the event, setting up, and taking down again, they made the service really effortless, friendly and fun, which meant I could focus on enjoying our day.

Guests are still talking about the pies! I caught one friend very happily devouring a huge tub of leftover mushy peas. i got to try two gluten free ones and they were both the tastiest pies I’ve ever had - have heard the same about all the others too.

If you have any doubts, trust me, you will not regret going with the Handmade Pie Company. Thank you again John and Tracy for helping to make our wedding such a happy day!

Certified review

Katie OMahony

• May 13, 2023

John and Tracy not only serve the most delicious pies, they also were an absolute pleasure to deal with. They had a lovely warmth and gave top quality service. Their selection of pies was amazing with superb flavours and the most gorgeous mash. They also went out of the way to offer fantastic service, brought extra pies just in case, met dietary requirements and just flexed to what we needed on the day. I wish them all the success with their future business. What a lovely couple - they deserve to be fully booked every week. Book them now!

Certified review


• April 29, 2023

Service and food was excellent. I can't thank John and Tracy enough for their friendly and professional service. Everyone loved the food. I would recommend them for an event indoor or outdoor.

Certified review

Steve Bartlett

• March 11, 2023

Great service from a lovely friendly team. Everyone loved the pies. John made a point of keeping in touch and updating me and was totally reliable. Would not hesitate to recommend this company- Thank you guys


Set List/Services