The handmade pie company

Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Verified bookings: 14
Reviews: 6
Book Safely - confirm booking via Poptop to receive Health & Safety Guarantee

Services From The handmade pie company in Sheffield

The handmade pie company

Amazing food makes an Amazing event, Handmade Pie Mash With Peas & Gravy

We are a husband and wife team that takes pride in the pies we make. Packed full of ingredients and made personally to order for your event.
From: £10 per person

Media Files

4 Photos


Price from: £6.75 per person

Bringing your amazing handmade pies with creamy buttery mash, Mushy peas and lashings of gravy

6 Reviews
Certified review

Charlotte Todd

Jan. 15, 2023

Our guests absolutely loved the food and everyone was complimenting the pies. Customer service was fantastic and John went above and beyond to make sure our guests had an amazing selection of pies.
Prices were reasonable given the quality that was served. Portions were fantastic.
John made sure the whole service was friendly, organised and just really good people to work with. I had assurance throughout the build up that the handmade pie company would deliver- and they did!

Thanks you for helping to make our day so special! Pies to remember forever!

Certified review

Dale Fielding

Dec. 17, 2022

These guys were great, from great communication with John ahead of the event and making sure everything was planned to perfection; through to being a pleasure on the night. John and Tracey were fantastic and approachable and and the food was absolutely spot on and perfect for a winter event. I couldn't recommend these guys more - thanks John and Tracey good food really does make for a good party!

Certified review

Ashley Schofield

Dec. 7, 2022

Everyone loved all the pies and even had seconds/thirds to take home!! Would definitely book again. They were friendly and made our people feel at ease during the event which was lovely. Highly recommend!

Certified review

Harpreet Chohan

Oct. 15, 2022

We decided to use The Handmade Pie company for our Anniversary party with friends and family, catering for 60.
I was impressed with the reliable and responsive contact I had whilst planning the event, in making sure everything was as we wanted. When the team arrived, they were friendly, helpful and encouraged us to enjoy our event taking all pressure off us.
The set up was professional and all of our guests were so impressed with the service. The pies were DELICIOUS, we’ve had messages about them all day. Thank you for making our event a night to remember with your wonderful pies.

Certified review


Sept. 24, 2022

John and Tracy supplied pies for our birthday party. The food was delicious, and the service was excellent. I will definitely be using them again in the future and would have no problems recommending The Handmade Pie Company.

Certified review

Lynn Priestley

Sept. 17, 2022

John and Tracy were absolutely fantastic at our daughters 21st Birthday party on our family farm. Communication from the time of booking to the day itself was first class and put us at ease from the first contact.
The food was excellent, it was fresh, piping hot and fantastic quality. We will highly recommend them and definitely be using them again.
The Priestley family in Nottingham


Set List/Services